Does female promiscuity
level out the male-female height difference?
June 18, 2004
World Science Staff
Scientists generally believe competition
among males explains why they're bigger than females in many species: the
males evolve heft through generations of fighting over females.
But a University of Arkansas researcher
claims science has overlooked females' role in this. Females can reduce the
size variance by mating promiscuously -- or, to put it more generously,
resisting male "monopolization," says the researcher, Michael
Plavcan.
The reasoning is that in order for the males
to grow in size over evolutionary time, their fight for dominance must
actually be successful. In other words, the bigger male needs to get and keep
the girl. But libertine females are able to frustrate that achievement, and
thus reduce the amount by which males evolve to be larger.
He analyzed 35 primate species and found
greater size variance strongly associated with less promiscuity, supporting
the hypothesis, he says. The findings are to be published in a peer-reviewed
book, "Sexual Selection in Primates" (Cambridge University
Press).
Plavcan says it's unclear whether his
analysis applies to humans as well. Humans are generally classified as
monogamous. However, among humans, the male-female size variance is small for
primates -- as it is among the species with more promiscuous females. And
"If you go around to hospitals, depending on the economic status [of a
couple], between 10 and 15 percent of offspring are not that of the stated
father," Plavcan adds.